An Accidental Creation
When Wizards of the Coast was preparing the launch of Magic: The Gathering in 1993, founder Richard Garfield and art director Jasper Myrfors commissioned fantasy illustrators to provide artwork for hundreds of individual cards. Artist Mark Poole was tasked with creating an illustration for Tropical Island, one of the ten original dual-color land cards designed for the game's debut Alpha release.
Poole painted a vibrant, detailed piece depicting a dense jungle island. To add life to the environment, he placed a multi-colored bird prominently on a tree branch in the foreground. When the artwork arrived at the publisher's office, Garfield immediately recognized a visual problem. The bird dominated the composition so completely that playtesters and readers would naturally assume the card represented a creature rather than a geographical location.
Repurposing the Canvas
Standard production practice might have called for rejecting the illustration or asking the artist to paint over the foreground. Instead, Garfield chose to keep Poole's canvas intact and build an entirely new card around it.
Garfield wrote a brand-new card concept specifically matched to the painting. He assigned it a cost of one green mana, flying capability, zero attack power, one toughness, and the ability to tap for one mana of any color. The card was named Birds of Paradise. Meanwhile, Poole was asked to paint a replacement piece for Tropical Island, which focused strictly on the palm trees, beach, and ocean landscape without any prominent wildlife in the foreground.
"The bird in the foreground was so dominant that Richard Garfield invented a new creature card rather than waste the artwork."
The Impact of a Format Staple
This spontaneous design decision created one of the most enduring game pieces in Magic's history. Birds of Paradise established the concept of the "mana dork"—a cheap creature deployed on the first turn to accelerate a player's mana pipeline—as a core strategic column of green deck construction.
For years, Birds served as a benchmark for mana acceleration across multiple play formats. Poole's artwork remained the official visual representation of the card through core set printings for over a decade before new visual variations were commissioned for later expansions and promo releases.
Poole's Expanding Legacy
Mark Poole contributed artwork to dozens of early Magic cards, including iconic Alpha pieces like Ancestral Recall, Counterspell, and Howling Mine. His painterly, traditional style played an instrumental role in defining the aesthetic identity of early Magic: The Gathering.
The story of Birds of Paradise remains a classic example of early trading card game development, where production resourcefulness and artistic flexibility directly shaped gameplay mechanics. An artwork originally intended to represent a land card ended up creating one of the game's most celebrated creatures.




